Toby Goodshank Original Art 2025

Death of Charlie Kirk

In American History X, Edward Furlong’s character says, “It’s always good to end a paper with a quote. He says someone else has already said it best. So if you can’t top it, steal from them and go out strong.”

That line led me to think of Michael Scott in The Office when he says, “Well, this is gonna hurt like a motherfucker.”

The visceral feel of a deep hurt encapsulated my entire being. I wasn’t able to do much yesterday after I heard the initial news. I had to go to a meeting and when I returned home, I learned that he had succumbed to his injuries and died.

I saw the actual shot, which a reporter described as something you would see if they had created a movie about an assassination—the textbook image of a kill shot.

And just like the uncontrolled flow of blood from his neck, my body lost its ability to cope and I wept. Tears poured gently down my face.

My family was understanding, but not completely. They couldn’t fully grasp why their father was so deeply hurt, affected, and cut by this tragedy.

I’ve had to sit down and think about why this death has shaken me so greatly. I was a fan of Charlie Kirk. I appreciated his viewpoint, his faith, his fortitude, and his courage to debate. How many of us, when we hold a viewpoint, say nothing? How many of us cower in fear of the mob, of loss, of financial blowback that could threaten our livelihoods?

He was a real-life Alex P. Keaton from Family Ties: the young upstart who believed in Ronald Reagan, freedom, capitalism, American greatness, and a great big beautiful tomorrow.

When I went on social media, I saw another side: people who were happy, joyous, even celebrating. The chickens coming home to roost. The gleeful nods of those who felt that a cosmic wave of justice had delivered its just desserts.

It reminded me of another quote from Goodfellas. Before Joe Pesci’s character shoots Spider, he’s mocked and someone asks, “What is the world coming to?” After shooting him dead, he answers chillingly, “That’s what the fuck the world is coming to.”

That’s where we are now. We are not able to communicate. We are tribal. We are animals. We objectify, dehumanize, and then kill one another.

Charlie knew how dangerous a lack of dialogue could be. He once said, “When people stop talking, really bad stuff starts. When marriages stop talking, divorce happens. When civilization stops talking, civil war ensues.”

He made his life about speaking up and speaking out. Going to campuses and engaging the youth of America in dialogue and debate.

He had a viewpoint and an opinion.

It’s not just that he was killed—that cut deeply enough. It was the absolute joy people expressed in his death. The frenzied glee of those salivating at the demise of a human being, of a husband and father.

Social media is filled with one-line justifications for any heinous act. The excuses for their jubilation were absurd: Didn’t he say this? Didn’t he support that? And the most damning, his statement:

“I think it’s worth to have a cost of, unfortunately, some gun deaths every single year so that we can have the Second Amendment to protect our other God-given rights.”

Yes, he did say that freedom has a cost—a cost that he ironically had to pay himself.

But where is the humanity? Where is the empathy? Why can’t we accept that people can hold different opinions? Why not ask why they believe what they believe instead of screaming at them, hitting them, or murdering them?

I am angry. Angry because I can’t fully articulate. I am tired of being reasonable and level-headed. Inside there is just a monster of pure emotion, rage searching for release. Take a breath, you know better.

Justice? There is no justice. Not because someone won’t be caught, punished, or even executed. There is no justice because you cannot undo what has been done. You cannot bring this young man back. His wife and kids will never see their father or feel his embrace again. He cannot be replaced with like kind or quality. He was special, unique, one of a kind. President Trump called him “even Legendary, Charlie Kirk.” And we know that legends never die.

When asked on a podcast how he wanted to be remembered, Charlie responded:

“I wanna be remembered for courage, for my faith. That would be the most important thing. The most important thing is my faith in my life.”

So now, as a new day begins, we still feel the loss. The tears still come. But I also feel the weight of his words. In the final scene of Spartacus, as the hero is silenced on the cross, his men stand and shout, “I’m Spartacus!” They refuse to let his mission die with him.

Maybe the way forward is not just to grieve his death, but to take up that mission. If Charlie’s voice is silenced, then ours must grow louder.

I am Charlie Kirk.

Comments

3 responses to “Death of Charlie Kirk”

  1. butterymagicaleff38b3e4f Avatar
    butterymagicaleff38b3e4f

    Did you think about the ‘why’ he was shot when you were writing this? Did you think about all of the hateful, hurtful, disgusting things he has said over the years? The hateful rhetoric that quite literally made him famous? His faith? Really? If you or he were a true person of faith, such vile things about your fellow human beings wouldn’t even flow into your stream of consciousness let alone out of your mouth-or from pen to paper.

    He wasn’t ’special or unique.’ He was a person who was made famous because of his extremist platform. He did nothing courageous, and it’s weird why you and people like you think he did. I served our country for 20 years in the military-I’ve witnessed actual courage.

    There’s nothing wrong in standing up for what you believe in-that’s a fundamental right afforded to us as US citizens; however, when what you believe in is meant to be degrading and hurtful, fomenting hate from your followers to others, that line from having a right to inciting more hate, is crossed.

    I didn’t rejoice in the murder of another human being by yet one more act of violence by the use of a gun; however,,I am offended that you and others are putting this person up on a pedestal when all they ever did was create controversy by their hateful words and opinions. No worries, as I’m sure there will be another person as equally as vile with their words, to replace him. Who knows, maybe in your grief you’ll find a way to take up his ‘cause.’

    I wish you peace-it seems like you and he needed it. I hope you find some and also gain some perspective as to why words can indeed hurt people-maybe ask people he vilified who weren’t straight, white ‘Christian’ men who because he of his words and clearly lack of Christian compassion, made them targets of violence.

    Like

    1. Jimmy Avatar

      Thank you for your comment, and thank you for your service. I agree that military service and defending our country is a higher form of courage.

      We are Americans. We should be able to speak and disagree without violence. Harming or killing someone over a viewpoint is never acceptable.

      I do not share your characterization of him. We can disagree on assessments, but the larger point remains: in this country we are free to hold different opinions, and that freedom must not cross into violence. Even in a divided moment, we still share more than we think. At minimum, we can stand together on that.

      Like

      1. butterymagicaleff38b3e4f Avatar
        butterymagicaleff38b3e4f

        It is a fact that because of the ignorant hate he espoused and spewed, people were hurt. He was proud of the buses of people he sent to the US capital on January 6, 2021. He was demeaning and degrading to people who were not white Christian men. People have pontificated about his ‘ability’ to have ‘spirited discourse.’ I disagree with that kind of ‘admiration.’

        While he may have reined it in on college campuses, in his own words on his podcasts, he said A LOT of despicable things. Two days before his murder he posted this: “Islam is the sword the left is using to slit the throat of America.’ In a singular post he denigrated an entire religion as well as accused people of a different political ideology in the US, of bringing down our country, in a disgusting euphemism.

        I don’t applaud his murder-but quite frankly I’m sick of the white-washed version of the person he was, what he espoused, and what he said! Let’s be real-the original poster/author compared his murder to that of MLK, Jr and JFK. Imagine comparing a person who was only famous for the controversy he created, to those two men. And then Spartacus. A man who escaped slavery and started a revolt basically about surviving and having rights. Kirk was NO Spartacus.

        Yes, we should disagree without resorting to violence; however, you don’t get to be the person holding the match to the kindling that starts the decimating forest fire, only to have people pretend they never saw you in the vicinity of the fire.

        Like

Leave a comment